top of page

Pick up the pencil

Nov 3
2 min read

A short think piece by Nathan Hawthorne


"Hi, we were wondering if you would be interested in promoting our new product..."


E-mails like this used to get me incredibly excited. I love trying out new products, systems, and programs, and when I find something good I like sharing it with others. Throw in the added bonus of a paid sponsorship and you'll have me singing in the rain.


But recently I've been getting more and more of these e-mails asking me to promote programs and products that are built around generative AI (LLMs). This offends me on two levels. Firstly, it means that you do not know me or my work, it means you have not taken the time to have even a glancing look at the decades of hard work spent building Hawthornearts from the ground up since my teen years. Secondly, it shows that you don't truly value what exactly it is that artists and their audiences across all disciplines are trying to do, and what it is they offer to the world.


Whether it be art, comics, written stories, film, poetry, music or animation, the human stories of the artist are a unique response to this world and to this life that only that individual can tell in the way they're telling it. No algorithm, no shortcut, no formulaic generated system can provide that.


When I read a book, I know that the writer has chosen those specific words for a reason. When I see a piece of art, even if there are errors in it, I understand how the artist struggled to get to a point where a piece like this is possible. When I hear a piece of music performed and see the artists eyes shut as they sing that high note I feel the emotion in my chest. And I love it all, and I connect with it all. It is so beautifully human.


And the same goes the other way. In the creation of these pieces of art we tear ourselves apart and put it out into the wild. We expose our hearts to the public upon each release and ask them "do you understand me?".


What machine can do that?


And so I encourage all of you, to understand the uses of AI, to understand its pros and cons, to understand its uses and what it can give, but also what it takes away. AI by its nature is not bad, it is a tool like any other - but as a shortcut, or as a replacement for the things that are oh-so-human, it simply cannot measure up to the human touch, it cannot reach the heights of even my weakest student.


This is not an argument against AI generated art. There is no battle, humanity already won. Instead this is a call to the creatives young and old out there who continue to hone their skills: Do not take the easy way out, pick up the pencil and make some art.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • Pinterest
bottom of page
google.com, pub-1551757961179858, DIRECT, f08c47fec0942fa0